It was a historic season for Levittown and Island Trees soccer at the high school level, one that was reflected in the amount of post-season awards received by members of the area's best teams.
Listed below are award winners for each team. If a district release was provided to Patch, and a link is available for it, the link is attached. The names of players honored are listed after the links:
MacArthur High School
- Girls Soccer (State Champion)
- (Co-)State Player of the Year, Class AA: Jill Mulholland
- All-State Teams (team number in parentheses): Mulholland (1st), Kelly Kempf (2nd)
- Football
- All-County: Brett Ellers and Will Cheshire
- All-Conference: Anthony Giametta, Gerard Cunningham, Joe Tangredi
- Academic All-Conference: Cheshire, Giametta
- Nominee, Nassau Unsung Hero Award: Kevin Roach
Division Avenue High School
- Girls Soccer (County Finalist)
- All-State: Alexa Schneider (1st), Krista Fitzpatrick (3rd)
- Conference I Player of the Year: Schneider
- All-County: Schneider, Fitzpatrick, Maggie Carew
- All-Conference: Susan Ballantyne, Alyssa Fiore, Taylor LeBright
- All-Class: Joanna Capitelli, Gina Fader
- Scholar Athlete: Capitelli
- Boys Soccer
- Conference Player of the Year: Shane McLaughlin
- All-County: McLaughlin
- Scholar Athlete Award: Michael Severance
- All-County Honorable Mention: Jonathan Anderson
- All-Conference: Alex Caba, Enzo Jerez, Nick LeBright, John Hauschild
Island Trees High School
- Boys Soccer (County Finalist)
- All-Region (encompasses Delaware, Pennsylvania, New Jersey and New York): Adonis Martinez
- All-State: Martinez
- Nassau County Paul LeSueur Overall Coach of the Year Award: Graham Radcliffe (Radcliffe is the first coach in school history to receive the award.)
- Conference Coach of the Year: Radcliffe
- All-County: Martinez, J.T. Famularo, Mike Gronenthal
- All-County Honorable Mention: Nick Alvanja, Anthony Leonick
- All-Conference: Chris Burns, Ralph Falcone, Lucas Panebianco, Jose Carvajal
- Girls Soccer (Conference II Champs)
- All-State: Allison Merrill (2nd)
- Senior Scholar Athlete: Maggie Milonakis
- All-County: Merrill, Bridget Vilbig
- All-Class: Kristen Breihof, Brianna Ferrara
- All-Conference: Alexa Dolgos, Marianna Ferraro, Nicole Pellegrino
- Football
- All-County: Chris Pascali
- All-Conference: Kyle Nigro
- Island Trees Unsung Hero: Brendan Reilly
- National Football Foundation/College Hall of Fame Scholar Athlete Finalist: Tyler Byrne
Steve Ellers, Graham Radcliffe and Maureen McLaughlin contributed to this report. If you see a team or an award missing, you can email information and/or photos to justin.izzo@patch.com and it will be added to this article.